Friday, October 30, 2026

Flashback, October 1966: McMurtry’s ‘Last Picture Show’ Opens Window on Stunted Texas Lives

Like Thomas Wolfe and Grace Metalious, Larry McMurtry caused a scandal in his hometown with a novel widely seen as based too closely on real events. 

Though he dedicated The Last Picture Show, published 60 years ago by Dial Press, to the residents of Archer City, Texas, many inhabitants were not thrilled by the attention they received in the first of what he called his “Thalia Trilogy,” nor with the acclaimed 1971 film adaptation by Peter Bogdanovich.

David Streitfeld summarized the local reaction in a biography of McMurtry that came out earlier this year, Western Star: 

“There were roughly three camps: Those who thought Larry made it all up. Those who thought Larry was exposing real incidents and real people and he should be ashamed of himself. And those who thought Larry was exposing real incidents and real people and, well, good for him.”

Many saw the novelist himself in one of the two teenage friends at the center of the story, Sonny Crawford. He denied it (though he did own up to identifying with the later midlife struggles of Sonny’s buddy, Duane Moore).

Others said they were the originals of certain characters—notably Ceil Cleveland Footlick, who even wrote a 1997 memoir titled Whatever Happened to Jacy Farrow? in which she claimed to be the inspiration for the teasing teen temptress who creates emotional havoc for Duane, Sonny, and other males in their high school.

McMurtry benefited from a legal environment in which prior obscenity legislation was being overturned, enabling him to depict multiple affairs, conducted almost as much out of boredom as anything else, in his fictional “Thalia” —a name he appropriated from another community, thereby annoying them, too.

Lacking intellectual stimulation, its residents are soon also without entertainment as the local cinema gets ready to close. Stuck, and barely aspiring to go anywhere, they find in sex an outlet to ward off frustration, cruelty, loneliness, despair, and death.

Particularly at that time in American life, readers (and, later, filmgoers) concentrated more on what seemed like McMurtry’s prurient treatment of such matters than on his poignant examination of aimless lives.

Playing the moral center of Thalia, “Sam the Lion,” veteran character actor Ben Johnson demurred over saying one line he deemed objectionable, concerned what his mother would say if she saw him the film. (Eventually Bogdanovich convinced him it was necessary, and Johnson ended up winning a Best Supporting Actor Oscar.)

The seeds of the novel were evident in a McMurtry short story, “There Will Be Peace In Korea,” published in the Winter 1964 issue of Texas Quarterly and focusing on Duane and Sonny as they try to reestablish their friendship before Duane ships out to Korea. Even that was the residue of the writer’s discarded idea of interconnected short stories modeled on Sherwood Anderson’s Winesburg, Ohio.

Two years after the publication of the Texas Quarterly article, McMurtry had completed a novel that, while departing from the Winesburg idea, still managed with admirable concision to depict the stunted lives of a whole spectrum of Thalia inhabitants.

Critical reaction to The Last Picture Show was mixed, ranging from dismissal (“seems derived from other novels about the sexual plight of the adolescent”—The Los Angeles Times) to enthusiastic (“perhaps the most honest, compelling and masterful novel ever written by a Texan”—The Houston Post).

McMurtry’s parents presented a more united front, in opposition, with his mother hiding the book in the closet and his father asking plaintively of college-educated Larry, “Good Lord, son, with all the words you know, couldn’t you have used some others?”

Four sequels to The Last Picture Show followed, steadily more depressing and less acclaimed: Texasville (1987), Duane’s Depressed (1999), When the Light Goes (2007), and Rhino Ranch (2009). How much of that was due to McMurtry’s eye for possible future adaptations and how much to the physical and emotional ills of the novelist’s later years is an open question.

But the achievement of the original novel—and of the exquisite film made from it—remains.

(The image accompanying this post comes from the film The Last Picture Show, featuring, from left to right, Timothy Bottoms, Jeff Bridges, and Cybill Shepherd as Sonny, Duane, and Jacy.)

No comments: