The creation of Edward Hyde, the embodiment of pure
evil in the physical ugliness so vividly portrayed above, is what has led so
many to view this “Strange Tale” as a horror story.
But there is another horror that, to Dr. Henry
Jekyll, might be just as dismaying: Hyde’s creator and opposite is not a saint,
but the same old Jekyll: a proper, basically decent Victorian gentleman who
cannot banish his primal urges—“that incongruous compound of whose reformation
and improvement I had already learned to despair.”
According to a fascinating Huffington Post piece by Melanie Kendry, “When Does a Man Become a Monster?”, the original draft by Robert Louis Stevenson indicated that
the crime of the “ordinary secret sinner” Jekyll was not murder (or even the consorting with prostitutes shown in so many cinematic versions) but
homosexuality.
It was an anticipation of a later, wittier, but equally
horrifying story of a double man in Victorian society, Oscar Wilde’s The Picture of Dorian Gray. Such were
the taboos of the time in England, however, that even in the latter, more
daring case, Gray’s secret sexuality could only be implied.
(The image accompanying this post shows John Barrymore, in the classic 1920 silent film version of Stevenson’s novella.
Remarkably, Barrymore depicted the violent and disturbing physical
transformation into Hyde without benefit of special effects. As fine as the
1933 Fredric March performance was—worthy enough of an Oscar---I still prefer
Barrymore’s. I may be the only person I know who still recalls Kirk Douglas’ performance in a 1973 TV musical adaptation of the tale by composer Lionel
Bart. That production was a horror story all its own!)